Showing posts with label Rules. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rules. Show all posts

Thursday, April 25, 2019

Rules, Choices, and Endgames, Cont.

The point of discussing endgames, chess moves, micro-managing and the like was to help highlight the signs/symptoms of when we're stuck in a losing endgame, and what sorts of things to consider to break out of it.

Obviously we can't go back in time and fix something the past, but we can draw a map for the present and future.

For example, if you're a team lead and feel stuck between doing a task yourself or failing, figure out what you need to do for the immediate situation (if you've got the time, proceed to the next step... but I understand if you don't have the time you might have to do something else just to get through it), and look at your 'unreliable' subordinates. Go ahead and assign them something, just make sure you have a plan to monitor their progress and ensure it gets done. Specifics are, as always, situation dependent. It can be anything from telling them "send me a quick e-mail telling me where you're at before you go home at night" to "write a report" or "brief me at our weekly staff meeting".  Do your best to put the burden of keeping you informed on the one who knows the situation best (i.e. the person assigned to the task) and make sure you've got time to fix things if they fall behind.

You're not off the hook, of course. Any time you give an assignment like that, you have to be prepared to notice if/when they don't follow through. If you say "send me a quick update" and they forget to do so, you have to say something. Saying something shows you're paying attention, and since most people try to keep the boss happy they'll probably try harder to remember (depending on the specific people involved.) If, however, they don't send the update you requested and you fail to say something, you've shown that they can blow you off with no consequences.

Be prepared to document if needed, because by the end of this they will either be a productive member of your team or you'll have documentation showing that they're not.

You should have those sorts of thoughts any time you feel stuck with unpalatable choices, really. Take the soccer cheating scenario - if you feel you have to either cheat or lose, consider what you can do to clean up the sport. Maybe try to have a meeting discussing the problem, and asking everyone (without pointing fingers) to commit to playing a clean game. The specifics will depend on the exact situation, the people involved, etc... so don't take this as a real suggestion.

The point is to consider your options, not to let your choices be constrained to unpalatable options, and if you can't fix it immediately, start working on a long-term plan to change your future choices.

And, for the purposes of these posts, recognize when you need to pull back a bit and look for these sorts of options.

Tuesday, April 23, 2019

Rules, Choices, and Endgames

I don't claim to be a fantastic chess player, though at one point I was fascinated by the endgame. There was some site or game or something that would give you an in-progress chess game and tell you how many moves it should take to reach checkmate, so it basically focused just on the endgame.

The thing about it is, at some point checkmate becomes inevitable. When the king is in check the only move available is to get the king out of check, so your choices become constrained. If there is only one way to move the king out of danger, your opponent can predict your move and act on it... generally by placing your king in check yet again.

If you want to win (or at least avoid losing) it does no good to go back a turn, because your choices are still constrained and there's only one move available. You would have to go back four or five (or however many moves - I hear chess grandmasters may be able to see 15-20 moves ahead) and do something different there.

While there are problems with drawing too many parallels between a game (no matter how complex) and the real world, I think this is a reasonable one - sometimes your options narrow, and you get too focused on taking the immediate logical action, and really you should think over how you got there and go back four or five steps to make a change there. Obviously you can't turn back time, but life isn't a turn-by-turn game, and you probably have a similar situation in the present. Choose differently.

This all would make more sense if I gave an example, so here goes.

Leading people is tough. When your only responsible for yourself and the boss gives you an assignment, you know what to do. Do the work, make the boss happy, look good. You put in the work, you decide if it's acceptable, and if you procrastinate or do a poor job that's on you.

When you're a leader, and the boss gives you an assignment, your reputation and job depend on other people doing theirs.

And you'll very quickly learn that you can't just give someone an assignment and leave it at that. They forget, or your tasking gets buried under 20 e-mails as they deal with their most recent request, or they get sick, or their kids get sick, or their car breaks down, or they've fallen behind and don't want the boss (aka you) to know and are desperately trying to fix it before you find out.

Really, when you have an employee who reliably gets stuff done they are gold, they make your job So. Much. Easier. (And then you tend to go to them for all your critical tasks, and they get overworked and burnt out while they're colleagues collect the same paycheck for doing hardly anything, and ultimately you lose.)

Inexperienced people managers are a bit like a checked king. Only one or two (or, if I include the scenario with the 'go-to' employee, three) moves seem obvious, and they're next logical step, but each move ultimately leads to checkmate.

The first move is to just do it all yourself. You know you can get the job done, and get it done right, and you can't trust your people to do the same. So you just stay a little later to work on it, or come in earlier. Devote your morning to it, or lunch.

There's all sorts of problems with this, though. If you're doing you're employee's job, you're probably not doing yours. There's only so much one person can do, and there's a reason you were given a team to lead... trying to do the work of a team all by yourself is a recipe for failure. (If you can't grow as a leader to the point where you're not doing this, you shouldn't be in a leadership position.) Not only that, but it tends to be demotivating to your employees, who aren't given the chance to grow and excel. They'll underperform, and kick even more work your way, and they won't be happy.

The second move is to micromanage. If you can't rely on your people to get it done without supervision, you supervise... and then some. Now, to be fair, some people may need a hefty degree of supervision. Part of your job is assessing where your people are and giving them that appropriate level. Maybe you've got a new hire who needs a lot of oversight, maybe you've got a twenty-year veteran who already knows what to do. You've got to figure out where they're at and what level of support they need, because if you supervise that veteran like a new hire they'll get upset that you won't just let them do their job... and if you neglect to provide the supervision that new hire needs, you're setting them up to fail.

Not only that, but again - if you're doing this you're not doing the job you were really hired to do, and one person can not do the work of five. Or, in this case, one person will run themselves ragged trying to micromanage a group of people. Maybe you spend one hour watching over one person's work, and the next hour watching over someone else's... and the moment you're no longer peering over the shoulder of the first person, maybe they'll switch to watching youtube videos or something.

What you need to do is go four or five moves back, before you feel compelled to either do it yourself or micromanage your subordinates, and put in the work to build your team.

This is not a quick or easy solution, and it requires a lot of work. In my most recent job, for example, we had a clear policy on how to deal with a new hire. They were assigned a more experienced employee to train them on the specific steps (how to log in to your voice headset, how to find locations in the warehouse, best practices for ensuring you counted the correct number of parts, etc.) That's time my trainer, generally a good employee or they wouldn't have been picked to train, isn't actually producing. And our company had forms to use for a 30-day, 60-day, and 90-day meeting where we'd give the new hire feedback on how they were doing. You had to be clear on what your expectations were, what the standards were, and how well they were doing at meeting those standards. Maybe you'd have to give them a bit more time with the trainer, or maybe they picked it up quickly and easily. That's all person-specific.

You do something similar for all your employees, though they may not need quite as much attention as a new hire. Unless they're underperforming, and then it's (again) giving them time with a trainer, and providing feedback, and documenting it... you want to give them the tools to succeed, everything they need in order to do so... and if they still can't do it, then maybe this isn't the right position for them.

This example was for a warehouse environment where there is pretty clear standards on what's expected. It's a little trickier if you're a person managing other people managers, or managing something less clear cut. I think one of our instructors at the Captain's Career Course had a great analogy for that:

Imagine you're a Captain in your office, sitting at your desk, and your young Lieutenant comes in carrying a huge, slimy, smelly fish that s/he promptly dumps on your desk. Now, you may be tempted to yell at the LT to take the fish out of there (as one of my classmates suggested when the instructor asked what you'd do... though that wasn't the answer he was looking for), and you may be tempted to just do whatever it takes to get the smelly thing out of there... but, as a people leader, what you really should do is talk the LT through how to handle the big ol' smelly thing, and then get him/her to dispose of the fish as you'd discussed.

You're teaching that subordinate how to handle difficult problems. What sorts of things to consider, where to go, etc. Then the next time s/he gets a smelly fish, they'll know exactly what to do.

Do that often enough, and your team will know what's expected of them, how to handle any problems, and can pretty much run itself.  (A half-truth. There's always turnover, always new hires and under-performers, and drama between people who just can't get along... it's just that you'll have that regardless of whether you've done what I've suggested or not, and it really is easier if you don't have to worry about everyone.)

This gives you more time to sit in your office playing solitaire. J/k. It means you'll have the time you need to, you know, plan ahead. Coordinate for the ammo and other supplies for weapons qualification next month, or figure out how to procure an extra computer and printer, or order the batteries needed for the picking headsets, or decide when you'll pull everyone out for annual training, or coming up with that lean six sigma project to improve the business, or working on some special project to please your boss, or whatever. Point is, you don't have to spend all your time doing the work your team should be doing (or standing over their shoulder in order to make it happen) and can devote yourself to other things.

You may have to put in a lot of effort up front, and at least a little effort in maintaining it, but this is how you build a team that can make yourself irrelevant (a good thing, really. Like that book about being a "One-Minute Manager" our ROTC instructor talked up back in the day. I've heard it said that the best leaders are smart and lazy, so they make their team do all the work, and it makes sense to me.)

To bring this back to my starting point - when a leader is doing all the work on their own, or micromanaging their employees, or assigning everything to their 'go-to' employee, it's a bit like when a king is in check during a chess endgame. Each move appears to be the next logical one given the situation, each step makes sense... and ultimately you're going to lose.

You need to go back four or five moves, and start doing something different there. Set your expectations, provide clear and consistent feedback, develop your people. Teach them how to handle problems on their own (and what criteria to look for when deciding to kick the issue up to you.) Get them to the point where they're confident and capable of handling it themselves. And maybe they'll come to you if they're trying to work with another department and that dept is being uncooperative, because you can reach out to your colleague there and sort things out (or kick it up to your boss, whatever.) You do the things that need done for your level, and make sure you have the resources on hand to set your people up for success.

To give another less business-related example (because I feel like it)...

When I first got paired with my Little through Big Brothers Big Sisters, her mom was always working and her grandma didn't want her in the kitchen because she didn't want to deal with cleaning up the mess. So one of the first things we did as a match was cook - I can't recall if it was cookies, or brownies, or a meal. Over the years we've cooked all of the above.

Anyways. Initially I had to go through everything in-depth. You know, 'this is how you read a recipe. That 'c' stands for cup. This is a one-cup measuring tool. That t or tsp stands for teaspoon. Here's a teaspoon, here's where you look to see whether it's 1 tsp or 1/2 tsp or 1/4 tsp. That T or Tbsp is a tablespoon. Here's a tablespoon. When you measure the flour, make sure you level it off so that the cup is full but not over full.  And here, the recipe doesn't call for it but I always add almond extract to the cookie dough, and cut the sugar in half. Or if you're making chili or something similar, just sniff your various spices and decide what smells like a good fit. Add it, taste it, see if you want add a little bit more.'

As she gained experience and grew confident, she started being able to do more and more of it herself. This, btw, is something most kids love. They'll excitedly demand that they get to crack the eggs this time, or measure out the flour. My Little would sometimes save recipes she saw online, and ask if we could make them. Or we'll be planning dinner and she'll look for recipes online.

You may have to peer over their shoulder the first few times, remind them that 'that's a small 't', not a bit 'T', so you've got to use the teaspoon not tablespoon', but they'll get better. Soon enough they'll be able to do it all by themselves (though generally it's a social activity, so it's not like I just leave her to it.)

As a Big in the program, I love teaching kids these sorts of things. First, cooking is a useful life-skill. It gives you options, and means you don't necessarily feel compelled to eat out all the time. Second, it's the sort of thing that gives children a sense of mastery. Let's them feel like they're capable of something, at least. People, especially children, need that. Need to feel like they're have things they can succeed at.

I've been matched with my Little for six or seven years now, and even though I'm not the only one who taught her how to cook (once she started doing it with me, she sometimes did it at home), I get a warm feeling when I see her use those skills, and use it well. I can't even describe how proud I was when she said she'd fixed dinner for her mother and grandmother all by herself.

That's the other thing, btw. Doing all that stuff? Setting people up for success, teaching, developing? It's rewarding as hell. Sure, giving feedback and documenting things can be a pain, but seeing someone succeed? Seeing them grow, and excel?

So. Rewarding.

Monday, April 22, 2019

Rules and Choices, Cont

I think there are a couple of mindsets that drive change (as opposed to supporting the status quo, which tbh most people do.)

All of them understand that the status quo is malleable, that they are free to choose something other than what currently exists. In other words, they understand that rules are meant to serve man, and not the other way around.

I generally categorize these change-leaders in a couple of ways, but that's just what I've come up with for this post and shouldn't be considered hard and fast.

You've got your idealists, who don't accept the status quo and believe something better is possible. For the driving analogy, they could be the ones who thought up stop lights, turn signals and the like. (Somebody had to, and it was definitely a change to the status quo at the time.) The main pitfall here is that idealists are not always grounded in reality, so the changes they make can have unintended consequences.

In one of my classes we were asked - is it better to have a good plan and poor execution, or a poor plan with good execution?

Imho, the poor plan with good execution is better, because part of executing a plan is checking to see whether it's working... and adjusting if needed. If you have good execution, that bad plan will eventually keep getting better and better, until it does what you wanted it to. Otoh, a good plan is useless if it's not executed very well, and can even be counterproductive. Especially if poor execution means people believe the idea itself is bad.  The point of all this? An idealist needs to have good execution skills, and the ability to adjust their plans if/when the results aren't what they wanted. It's too easy for an idealist to get caught up in their hoped for goal, and to forget or ignore any sign that things aren't working out as intended.

Somewhat related, and perhaps the same (though in my head they're different) are visionaries. Again, they see past the status quo, but imo the vision they have is a) not necessarily about ideals. I.e. they can have a vision of everyone owning a radio, or personal computer, or dishwasher. It's not about a 'better' world, per se, but it is a vision and b) they tend to be better at execution.

I think I make that distinction because we so often call people like Steve Jobs or Bill Gates 'visionaries', and effective execution is a key part of how they got there. Elon Musk, btw, could probably be tagged as a visionary. I remember when electric cars started being a thing, one of the problems with it was that there were not many places where you could publicly recharge your car. Elon Musk has not just built a bunch of electric cars, he's been working steadily to create an entire EV infrastructure to support them. I believe he's even been working to create solar paneled roofs, which would definitely boost the benefits of electrical vehicles.

There are other change-leaders, like the driver who uses the shoulder of the road to cut ahead of other cars, who know they're not bound by the rules... and seem to choose whatever benefits themselves. These guys are close cousins to the barracks-lawyers and rule-bend who don't really break the rules so much as twist and bend them in their favor. For these type of change-leaders, well... it's funny. From what I can tell, most of them probably don't think of themselves that way at all... or if they do, it's not for the same reasons. Why do I say that?

Because most of them would consider themselves 'realists'. That whole "I got mine, how you do?" attitude implies an acceptance that 'this is the way the world is'. They can be cynical, and worldly, and believe that 'it is what it is' and think that they're just doing what everyone else is doing.

Which means they don't really think they're changing anything. Or, if they are pushing a change, it's not about 'changing the world' (they know idealism is naive, and are too smart to believe that) so much as doing what it takes to win.

The problem here is again, the law of unintended consequences. They don't necessarily see the end result of the world their choices make, and don't necessarily want to live in that world any more than the rest of us do. They just think that that's already the way the world is, or that they're exploiting the loopholes in the world as it exists... as any smart person would do.

But they are changing the world, they live and breathe and model a world where that's just what people do, and in the process they make it more real.

There's one more pitfall I want to mention, one that can trip up any of these... from idealists to cynical realists, and in some ways it comes from their very strength... their willingness not to blindly accept the status quo.

See, in doing so there's a tendency to dismiss older rules and traditions as inconvenient, outdated, and irrelevant. Which sometimes is true, of course, and a necessary mindset for change. But traditions developed for a reason, they got passed down for a reason, and if you don't understand the purpose they served you can't accurately tell whether it's outdated, expired, and time to throw them away.

This is one area where, in another era, I would probably consider myself more conservative. Well, that's not quite true. It's just that I've seen far too many people do change for change's sake (or to look good to their boss) without actually improving anything. Like the receiving dock at my last work place, which was a prime target for 'lean six sigma' projects. The supervisor would come up with some plan to change the layout, supposedly to improve the efficiency with which product was received. Looks good to the boss, of course, since it shows you're always looking to improve the business (and have the execution skills to make it happen)... but if your change was really all that great, then why does another supervisor make another project out of redesigning the same area just four or five years later? Especially when there was no real system change to explain why a new layout would really be more efficient. If the first project had been done right, how could a new layout be more efficient? The same holds true almost everywhere, tbh, and I know some long time non-commissioned officers who internally roll their eyes as their leadership comes up with a 'new' plan that is pretty much exactly what they'd seen someone try five years prior.

If you're going to throw out the status quo, you should at least understand how that status quo came to be. It's sort of like a variation on Sun Tzu - "If you know the enemy and know yourself, you need not fear the result of a hundred battles. If you know yourself but not the enemy, for every victory gained you will also suffer a defeat. If you know neither the enemy nor yourself, you will succumb in every battle."

If you know the driving forces behind the status quo (as well as the other drivers of change) and know yourself, then you need not fear the result of a hundred battles. If you know yourself, but not the driving forces behind the status quo and other change drivers, for every victory gained you will also suffer a defeat. If you know neither the driving forces behind the status quo, the other change drivers, nor yourself, you will succumb in every battle.

Eh, that makes it a bit too long to by pithy, but I hope you get the gist.

Anyways, the point is that people are sometimes so determined to make changes that they see any obstacle as a threat to be overcome... and in the process they may undo the hard work of prior generations. Like removing the checks and balances generations of people fought hard for, because they don't really understand why those checks and balances were created in the first place, and just see them as an obstacle in their way.

The pitfall here is this: there's a natural tendency to overcome obstacles by consolidating or amassing enough power to smash through them. Again, it can lead to unintended consequences, and some pretty bad ones at that. (I want to go into this more in another post, but this is probably enough for today. To remind myself of the thread I want to pick up - it'll touch on the endgame in chess.)

 

Rules and Choices, Cont.

I had a few ideas for writing a post, but they just weren't coalescing. Or rather, the ideas ran in my head like a Choose Your Own Adventure, and went in different directions every time I thought about them.

I've been thinking about them for over a week (mostly), but what with the interview last week and various other things the thoughts slipped away. I don't think this post will be exactly what it would have been if I'd tried writing it earlier, but that's not necessarily a bad thing. I have a thread, a beginning thought that reminds me of some of the subsequent ideas...

Actually, there's two or three threads (i.e. drawing on the driving analogy a bit more, discussing the type of people who create change, and a bit on how to make responsible decisions. All interrelated, so they sometimes lead into each other and sometimes don't.) Unfortunately, they keep slipping away when I try to grasp them. Maybe I should have jotted them down last week.

Right. Well. Let's start with the driving analogy. I first mentioned drivers who always followed the rules (and often rely on that so much that they stop paying attention to other drivers, relying on everyone else to abide by traffic laws just like they are.) The only real pitfall here is that they can easily forget that they have a choice. The rules seem ironclad, inflexible, and their only job is to follow them. But the rules are created to make all of our lives easier, and if they aren't working it's up to us to change them. (and if they're wrong, it's up to us to speak out against them.) The rule-bound driver is basically giving up the conscious decision to choose the norms that create their world, though in doing so they still influence those norms... they just lend weight to existing norms. There's nothing really wrong with being a rule-abiding driver, and the more of these there are the more predictable driving is, but if you value "thinking outside-the-box", these are rarely going to do so. They're quite comfortably in-the-box, and often forget that there's anything outside of it. (You can also have someone aware enough to remember they have a choice, who then deliberately chooses to follow the rules. They generally support the status quo and don't look any different from the other rule-abiding drivers unless circumstances turn them into the type of driver who occasionally chooses to disregard the rules.)

The other drivers - the one willfully disregarding the rules in order to get somewhere faster, and the one who disregards the rules when unusual situations seem to require it - don't need reminded that they're free to drive how they want. That outside-the-box thinking helps them become drivers of change, because they're not just blindly accepting the status quo. But doing so puts more of the responsibility for their decisions on their own shoulders, as they're choosing to disregard accepted wisdom.

The rest of these posts will focus more on that - on how to use that power wisely. And, since the ones who use that power to abide by the rules are basically supporting the status quo, this is also about using that power to create change.




Sunday, April 21, 2019

Easter Update

Happy Easter, for those of you who celebrate it. (And best wishes for a good day to those of you who don't.)

Been a while since I posted - I had an interview Friday, and had to fly out for it Thursday. Wasn't entirely sure I would make it back as planned (flight got delayed about an hour or so, maybe because of the tornado warning in the area, though I'm not 100% certain of that. Missed the follow-on flight home, but the airline got me in on the next flight so I made it... Much later than I was supposed to, but oh well.)

Given that I had to be up at 5:30am local time, which was more like 4:30 my time, it made for a very long and exhausting day. (I hesitate to admit that I also had trouble sleeping the night before. I don't think I was nervous, per se, and the interview seemed to go well... but I kept wanting to jump the gun to what happens after I find whatever job I'm going to find. Like, if this particular interview goes well, the next step is probably a background check... which I ought to pass, but don't like counting on it until it happens. And you never know how long that would take, and can I really handle waiting indefinitely to finish this step? Assuming all of that works out, and I land the job, then what? Do I rent a place in my new location and move most everything there, then try selling the house? What about my pets? Most of it was pretty much pointless until I passed the interview stage and got an offer, of course. Meh. The position seems to fit my interests very well, so I kind of hope it works out... which means moving, and selling the house, so I also hope the house sells quickly - and at a reasonably good price - if/when it comes to that.)

Much though I do love traveling, there's always a part of me that is happy to get home and says "I don't want to go anywhere, I don't even want to think about it...

Not for another month, at least."

Which is why I'm debating whether or not I'll visit my folks next weekend. I flat out told them I wasn't coming up for Easter, since I knew I didn't want to try cramming in a four hour road trip right after flying back from my interview. But Dad holds that Easter is really an eight day event, and my brother didn't want to make the (20 minute) drive today if I wasn't going to be there, so my father really wants us to celebrate it next weekend.

If I was forced to decide in the immediate aftermath of traveling, it would be a surefire way to get told 'no', but I figure I'll wait a day or two and see if I feel differently.

I also wanted to note something that amused me, particularly in light of my recent posts. I used the hotel shuttle service to get to a couple of places, and on one of those trips a motorcycle driver moved onto the shoulder of the road to bypass a couple of cars that were going slower then s/he desired.

And on another trip, our shuttle was trying to merge into a somewhat busy highway... so we were stuck waiting until traffic moved. I saw a car drive on the shoulder of the road to get past us, which initially annoyed me... then I noticed them take the exit a few feet further, and realized they were doing exactly what I'd described in my previous post. They knew their turn was just ahead, and took the shoulder to get around all the people trying to merge onto the highway.

They were shortly followed by another car also driving on the shoulder, though I'm not sure if the second car had seen what the first car did and was imitating it, or came up with this on their own. The only problem is that this car wasn't actually taking the next exit, and instead tried getting ahead of the line of merging cars. In other words, an a-hole selfishly trying to get ahead.

Seeing three irl examples of driving decisions, just as I'd described in my posts, tickled my fancy. It also reminded me of an addendum I wanted to add -

The majority of the people can refuse to follow the rule breakers. That second car might (or might not) have been following the first one, but everyone else in the line chose not to. They may even have rolled their eyes and muttered 'a-hole', like I probably would have done, but they didn't decide to go drive on the shoulder of the road themselves.

As I keep saying, leaders can't lead people where the people don't want to follow. If you don't like the trend someone else is setting, then just keep on keeping on. Don't imitate them. If enough people choose likewise, that trend will quickly die.

In some ways, a-hole behavior like this presents a social dilemma of sorts. That is, if everyone chose to drive on the shoulder of the road (like that motorcycle and those two cars) then we all would lose. There'd be no place to go if/when emergency vehicles are trying to get past, and more people would suffer - and mayhap die. It would take too long for ambulances and police to reach the scene of an accident, which means it may also take too long to clear the road after an accident, which means the people in need of immediate help may not get it in time... and everyone else will probably be stuck in the ensuing traffic jam for even longer. We all lose.

If nobody drives on the shoulder to bypass traffic, then the shoulder is clear for emergencies. Either people pulling off to get out of the way of ambulances and police cars, or as a route the emergency vehicles can use to bypass everyone else and get to the scene of the accident.

What I witnessed, however, was a few a-holes giving themselves the privilege of bypassing traffic... probably with the hope and expectation that nobody else will do likewise, thereby giving them all the benefits without any of the consequences.

Which is why I'm calling them a-holes. They don't actually want anybody else to act like they're doing, and would probably be unhappy if everyone did. Their advantages rely entirely on doing something that nobody else is willing to follow their lead on, and yet (from my experience with the mentality) they probably look down on all the rule-abiding 'sheep' that are essential to making their behavior a success.


Sunday, April 14, 2019

Continuation of Rules, Choices, and Other Things

I figured it was time for a follow up to my previous post. There's actually a lot to it, so I suppose I ought to start unpacking it.

The drivers who follow the rules without thinking...

Well, they're not bad necessarily, though they can be inflexible and unprepared when the unexpected occurs. In this situation, their attitude towards following traffic rules exemplifies their attitude towards rules in general, and there are three issues with this.

First, you could probably replace such a driver with one of those self-driving cars and not notice any difference. That is, they're sort of acting without thought. Doing what they're programmed to do. To draw on all those religion classes as a kid, they seem like the type of people Jesus would want to remind that "The Sabbath was made for man, not man for the Sabbath."

It's like... they're basically turning off their own brain and accepting the wisdom of whoever created the rules in the first place.

Which, again, is not bad per se. It's just that you can't really outsource that sort of responsibility. There's a reason "following orders" is not considered an acceptable reason for committing war crimes. No matter how much the military (or society, or whoever) tries to instill blind obedience in you... you still choose whether or not you obey. And you have an obligation to recognize when orders are illegal, immoral, and just plain wrong... and to disobey when given such. You can't shove all the responsibility off on whoever gave you the order, because you are a thinking being who chose to accept and follow it. (When it comes down to legal cases I understand prosecution has been mixed, and I'm sure some of it is tied in with whether or not you were aware that the order was illegal in the first place, and how much you really knew when you decided to obey. Which is part of why it's important to teach people ahead of time what makes an order illegal in the first place, so that nobody can claim ignorance as an excuse.)

And (the third reason) if you believe that power corrupts than you'd understand that any organization, or person, given blind obedience grows corrupt more easily. History has repeatedly shown that all man-made organizations are vulnerable, whether we're talking religious, government or corporate. It's our willingness and ability to show that there are lines that shouldn't be crossed, orders that won't be followed, and that we are paying attention and will take action when things go too far that hinders corruption. Blind obedience enables abuse.

So the law-abiding drivers are, well... they're okay. Not bad. You might even say they're 'good'. But...

They're less than they're capable of being. Like they're half-asleep. Not thinking. Not fully engaged with the world around them. And (again drawing on that religious upbringing), you might even call them 'lukewarm'.

As for the driver careening through traffic, weaving in and out heedless of the havoc left in his (or her) wake...

I wouldn't call them a 'leader', though there is something about seeing someone choose a different path that tends to draw followers, so I suppose they are leading by example. It's just...

Okay, so they set the example for a different way of driving. And others, upon seeing it, decide they want to do the same. More and more people see such behavior and choose to imitate it, until eventually traffic (which previously consisted mostly of rule abiding drivers) now becomes a free-for-all that requires all your skill to navigate.

I won't say it's bad... some people may even find it exhilarating. Adrenaline coursing through their  body at yet another near-death experience on their daily commute. Then again, others may come home exhausted, stressed out by narrowly missing other cars five times on the way home, and swear to themselves that they are not leaving the house again unless they absolutely have to.

The point, though, is that someone modeled a behavior that was since imitated to such a degree that it entirely changed the nature of the commute. And if it was deliberate, if someone was trying to create that changed environment, then I would probably call it 'leadership'. But I suspect it was really just one person being selfish, someone with a disregard for the rules as applied to themselves, who wanted to get wherever they were going as fast as possible (and the idea that everyone would do the same, and would thus create an environment where they would be unable to pull the same tricks to speed through traffic, well... it probably never even crossed their mind.)

The third example is the trickiest and most complicated by far. They're the type of driver who, when stuck in a traffic jam and able to see their turnoff ahead, might drive on the shoulder to reach it. Like... they wouldn't drive on the shoulder  just to get further ahead, because cops and ambulances might need the shoulder to get to wherever the source of the traffic jam is. But if they can clearly see their turn off, and can get there without causing any sort of problems, they'll go for it. It's a win/win... letting them get out of the traffic jam sooner, and removing a vehicle from the congestion on the highway.

Or maybe they're turning on to another road, but they choose to wait until an oncoming car passes (even though, if they really hit the gas they could probably make the turn ahead of them) because they know they'll only be slowing down for another turn just down the road. There's no point rushing ahead just to brake again, especially when it forces the car behind you to slow down as well. It's like, if you personally hate having a car get in front of you only to brake seconds later... don't do that to the car behind you.

The point, with this driver at least, is that they're not blindly obeying the law... but they're also not selfishly disregarding it, either. And while I won't say every decision is made mindfully - all drivers  go on auto-pilot at some point or another - this driver is, in some ways, consciously creating the driving environment they want.

We, as a society, make a lot of 'thinking outside-the-box', and having a vision, and seeing beyond what is to what could be.

And that's important. It really is. It's something all the 'blindly obeying every traffic law' driver doesn't have, which also means they're not actively shaping the world around them.

But just because you've realized that social norms and conventions are as binding as tissue paper, doesn't mean that you're making good decisions about what to do with that realization.

What world are you creating? Is it one you'd really want to live in? (If not, well... you know what to do.)

Thursday, April 11, 2019

On Rules, and Choices, and Other Things

Ever see a fellow driver who appears totally zoned out? Like, they're following every law of traffic... but they don't show any sort of awareness of what other drivers are doing. Sometimes they even (to much annoyance) are driving in the left hand lane on a highway at the exact same (legal) speed as the car next to them. Which generally causes a blockage, as cars behind them aren't able to pass.

They technically are correct. They're going the speed limit, they use turn signals, they stop when the stoplight is red and go when the light turns green. And so on, and so forth. But the lack of awareness is disturbing, because they probably aren't going to react in time if someone else screws up.  They won't wait that extra second when the light changes, because they don't notice that another car isn't slowing down to stop.

Traffic rules are there for our safety, but they aren't enough to compensate for being an alert and aware driver (especially come winter, when the roads are slippery. Pausing that extra second or two can help prevent accidents if another car starts sliding through an intersection, for example.)

In almost the exact opposite fashion, there are people who seem to believe traffic rules are optional. And, I suppose, if you're alert and aware enough you may even get away with it. That's one of the things that made deploying seem a bit wilder and crazier, in a sense. It's not just the crazy driving our own soldiers had to do in order to stay safe. I recall seeing drivers - was it Kuwait? I think it was in Kuwait - driving the wrong way up a traffic ramp.

Of course, when you choose to disobey the commonly accepted standard you are taking a risk. Risks you can mitigate, of course, but risk nonetheless.

Once you realize that traffic rules are made for you, and that you aren't required to blindly obey them...

Well, responsible people will probably still follow the rules most of the time, because they know the rules were designed for everyone's safety. And if they occasionally don't, it's generally done for a reason (maybe the lights stopped working) and they take every precaution to make sure that nobody's endangered by their actions.

And then there's the people who decide to ignore most of the rules, zipping through lights, rapidly changing lanes to get through congested areas quickly... and completely unconcerned with whatever accidents they may cause along the way. Especially if they're not the ones who get hit. (After all, the other drivers should be paying better attention.)

This is, of course, a metaphor. But I've gotta get going, so I'll elaborate on it some other time.